First Year Teacher: 5 Important Behavior Management Plans to Develop

If you don’t do anything else before the school year starts, I encourage you to at least develop behavior management plans for your students. (and your sanity!) When kids know their boundaries and that they will be rewarded for following the expectations a healthy classroom environment is born.

5 Behavior Management Plans to develop- whole group, small group, and individual behavior plans

But, I definitely hope you do way more than just develop behavior management plans. You need to make sure to decide how you are going to set up and organize your classroom. I wrote a free ecourse that allows you to develop a plan for classroom organization in a week!

You’ll also want to make sure that you develop plans for routines so that you are prepared when those little munchkins come skipping (or crying) into your classroom in August.

This post may contain affiliate links. That just means that if you purchase something using a link I share, I get a percentage from that purchase. This helps me keep The Simply Organized Teacher going! You can read more in my disclosure policy

A behavior management plan is more than telling kids they are doing a good job and calling their name out loud when they are not following the rules.

A healthy behavior management plan involves mostly positive rewards and incentives paired with an understanding of the expectations. When those expectations are not followed, a consequence is given. We must make sure our students know what their boundaries are and that they see consequences when they cross them.

5 Behavior Management Plans to develop- whole group, small group, and individual behavior plans

(Obviously consequences aren’t for every.single.time. a kid makes a mistake, they are kids! But you know when a student is being defiant versus making a genuine mistake.)

Types of Behavior Management Plans

I believe in developing a plan for different behavior management plans. This doesn’t mean I use all of them at the same time (or even during the school year at all.) But it is important to have a plan in place before the school year starts so that when instances arise, you are prepared.

Whole Group Plan

This is a behavior management plan that rewards the whole group for good decisions, staying on task, and following directions. We must teach our kids how to work as a team and to help each other. When kids know they are accountable for the whole groups reward, there is more ownership in their behavior.

My favorite whole group management system is a marble jar. The class can earn multiple marbles at a time for choices that they are making. I add extra lines on the marble jar so that they can get rewards throughout the process.

5 Behavior Management Plans to develop- whole group, small group, and individual behavior plans

It’s important to keep this POSITIVE so I try to refrain from removing marbles unless I say something to my students like “I have 6 marbles here that you can earn during this lesson, but if you talk without raising your hand, I can take a marble away.” This way the expectations are set and if they don’t meet them, they see the consequence of their action.

You can also do things like a paper link chain, a brownie points pan, or adding letters to a “secret word” to foster engagement in positive choices.

Small Group Plan

This is a management plan developed to hold small groups or teams accountable. The first team to get their table picked up quietly and quickly earns a point. The most important point I want to make is that teams do not compete against each other but instead compete against themselves.

When I use this management plan, I am always intentional about finding something worth rewarding from even the WORST table! It is also important that once a team reaches the “goal amount” of points starts over, not the entire class. Because this is a small group management plan, other teams should not be held accountable or lose their rewards because another team has already met their goal.

Individual Plan

An individual behavior management plan is a positive reward system for when the student does something worth being recognized for. To me, this is the most important management plan to establish because it is a very visual way to reward kids for positive choices and remind other students that meeting expectations earns rewards.

I have always used a classroom economic system as my individual behavior management plan. You can read more about it on my Classroom Economic System post. In that blog I share about where that idea came from, how to implement an economic system, and how to manage it.

5 Behavior Management Plans to develop- whole group, small group, and individual behavior plans

Other individual management plans involve tickets that can be traded in for rewards and class dojo. The most important part of rewarding students individually is to be consistent and to verbally praise them for their choice and give them their tangible reward (money, ticket, point, etc.)

Also, not EVERY time a kid raises their hand needs to be rewarded. At the beginning of the year, YES! Do it ALLLLLL day long. But as the year progresses it is okay to back off a bit and allow kids the opportunity to make wise choices even if they aren’t receiving a reward.

Individual Plan for Challenging Students

Some years you will have some extra tough kids where the simple “great job, friend, here is your sticker” won’t work. In those situations you need to develop a more in depth plan for them. This is usually something I plan out all the details for when I actually need it. But the rough draft always involves a very scheduled out reward system

5 Behavior Management Plans to develop- whole group, small group, and individual behavior plans

These students need to be praised and rewarded FREQUENTLY! Sometimes multiple times a day. You can read more about the plans I developed for my challenging students this past year in my post on management tips for challenging students.

One thing I have always wanted to try and keep forgetting about in the hustle and bustle of the school year.

Love this idea! Pull a name from the Mystery Hero jar. Don't say their name, but let kids know you are watching your Mystery Hero. If the Mystery Hero does a good job reward them, and if they aren't on their best behavior just say to the class that the Mystery Hero needs to try harder. Don't call the student out or let students know who it was.

I have had friends use this and I think it is an AMAZING idea. Each morning one students stick is placed in the mystery student jar, at the end of the day if that student has made good choices they will be rewarded. If not, then their name is put back into the jar of sticks for a chance another day.

Class Meetings

Another way to foster positive behavior within the classroom is to incorporate class meetings.

I would recommend the book “Positive Discipline In the Classroom.” They break down step by step how to begin class meetings. Some of the projects are too much for younger grades (at least in my opinion) and have to be modified, but the messages behind them are important.

I conduct weekly class meetings. I try to do 2-3 a week in addition to a team builder or class builder on the other days. It is important to me that my students feel connected to the other members in their class and by sharing their highs and lows, feelings, and struggles connection is formed and trust is built.

5 Behavior Management Plans to develop- whole group, small group, and individual behavior plans

My friends Courtney and Tiffany from Mustard Seed Teaching write about The Fellowship of the Classroom and how class meetings are worked into that. They even show a video of how they work.

What are you planning on doing for your behavior management plans this year? I still want to do my money management system but “Jackson Bucks” don’t sound as alliterate as “Buchtien Bucks” so I am on the quest for a new name……..

My new ebook that launched last Saturday has a whole chapter dedicated to this topic of behavior management plans. You can click the link below to grab you own copy! I also write about time management, laying out a classroom, decorating a classroom, and much more!

Want classroom organization help? Be sure to fill out the form to schedule a time for me to come help you in your classroom!

Until next time,



5 Behavior Management Plans to develop- whole group, small group, and individual behavior plans

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *